KUALA LUMPUR: Economists have warned against the proposal for another round of withdrawals from the Employees’ Provident Fund (EPF), saying it would only result in long-term pains for all.
Prof Emeritus Dr Barjoyai Bardai noted that previous withdrawals had already left millions without pension savings, forcing them to work beyond retirement.
“If we are trying to help the poor and needy, we need to determine what they need this money for. If it is to pay their debt or overdue loans, then we can find other means to help them,” he told Astro Awani.
“Helping them is not by allowing them to withdraw their EPF savings, because that is for long-term investment.”
As of 2021, over six million contributors have less than RM10,000 in savings, of which three million have less than RM1,000 – far beyond the minimum RM240,000 that the EPF deems necessary in order to retire.
Geoffrey Williams, Dean of the Institute of Postgraduate Studies at the Malaysia University of Science and Technology, explained that more withdrawals would only worsen this systematic problem.
He warned that if a similar withdrawal of RM45 billion from last time was allowed, the total withdrawals would be RM200 billion or 20 per cent of the current EPF fund size.
“This smaller fund can cause lower returns for existing members and make it difficult for EPF to maintain a 6 per cent dividend. So everyone suffers,” he said.
“For the wider population, pumping RM45 billion into the economy under current conditions would cause inflation and higher interest rates. So again everyone suffers.”
A group of EPF contributors previously submitted a memorandum to Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim to consider a special EPF withdrawal of up to RM30,000.
Pertubuhan Aktivis Rakyat Malaysia (ProRakyat) said the early withdrawal was necessary as a short-term solution for those affected by the COVID-19 pandemic.
If approved, it would mark the fifth round of early EPF withdrawals in three years.
What are Putrajaya's alternatives?
Rather than another set of withdrawals, Barjoyai said it was crucial for the government to focus on boosting EPF members’ savings during their remaining period of employment.
Noting that the EPF only covered workers under formal employment, he also suggested expanding the country’s social protection system beyond the EPF through the establishment of a national social protection institution.
“The government can inject some assets into this foundation… to generate investment income,” he said. “As it accumulates over the next 10 to 20 years, we can see that this will be a credible institution to protect all citizens.”
However, Williams is of the view that boosting savings would be difficult for millions of people as current incomes were too low.
“Helping to raise incomes through better value-added jobs, encouraging multiple income sources through tax incentives and providing income support rather than subsidies should be used.”
He also called for the government to implement a universal basic income system, where “instead of lump sum payments twice a year, these should provide monthly income cash credits directly to (the people’s) bank account so they can spend as they choose and manage better”.
“Above all, we need full reform across the entire welfare and incomes system, including pensions, for long-term security for millions of people.”
Faye Kwan
Tue Jan 31 2023
As of 2021, over six million contributors have less than RM10,000 in savings, of which three million have less than RM1,000.
Rejim Zionis mara ke Jabalia, antara kem pelarian terbesar
Lokasi operasi rejim itu tertumpu di Jabalia, salah satu daripada lapan kem pelarian terbesar di Semenanjung Gaza.
[LAPOR LANGSUNG] Suspek serangan Balai Polis Ulu Tiram tiada kaitan kumpulan pengganas - KPN
Berita terkini insiden serangan Balai Polis Ulu Tiram yang mengorbankan dua anggota polis dan mencederakan seorang yang lain, pada Sabtu.
Filem terbaharu ‘The Experts’ tampil pelakon hebat, genre berlainan buat peminat
Filem dengan idea original ini menampilkan kisah fiksyen tentang rompakan yang melibatkan sebentuk cincin permata.
Dua tahun di Ulu Tiram, pulang ke sini jasad terbujur kaku’ - Bapa
Dia tidak menitiskan air mata sepanjang berada di Johor Bahru bagi menyelesaikan urusan jenazah anak keempat daripada lapan itu.
Malaysia, Uzbekistan akan tingkatkan kerjasama ekonomi - Tengku Zafrul
Malaysia dan Uzbekistan akan memperbaharui komitmen mereka untuk mengukuhkan hubungan ekonomi sempena hubungan diplomatik selama empat dekad.
Bimbang hilang suami antara faktor wanita tidak jalani saringan kanser
Bimbang kehilangan suami dan menjadi beban kepada keluarga antara faktor menyebabkan ramai wanita di Kelantan tidak menjalani saringan awal kanser yang disediakan LPPKN di negeri ini.
SUKMA-21: Sarawak mahu cipta rekod untuk naik imej sebagai kuasa sukan
Sarawak selaku tuan rumah temasya Sukan Malaysia (SUKMA) edisi ke-21 yang berlangsung bermula 17 Ogos ini, mahu mencipta rekod kejohanan untuk menaikkan imejnya sebagai kuasa sukan di negara ini.
Kelantan warta garis panduan baharu sukan Muay Thai - Exco
Kerajaan Kelantan sudah mewartakan garis panduan baharu berhubung sukan Muay Thai di negeri itu untuk diperkasakan dan dibangunkan semula bagi melahirkan atlet bertaraf dunia.
Pertumbuhan ekonomi rantau APEC dijangka cecah 3.4 peratus pada 2024 - Laporan
Pertumbuhan ekonomi di negara-negara Kerjasama Ekonomi Asia Pasifik (APEC) dijangka mencecah 3.4 peratus pada 2024 dan perlahan kepada 2.9 peratus pada 2025-2026.
Tempoh permohonan sertai Sidang Belia Wilayah Persekutuan dilanjut hingga 31 Mei
Tempoh permohonan keahlian Sidang Belia Wilayah Persekutuan (SBWP) dilanjutkan hingga 31 Mei ini, kata Menteri di Jabatan Perdana Menteri (Wilayah Persekutuan) Dr Zaliha Mustafa.
KWSP peruntuk RM97 bilion bagi pelaburan domestik pada 2023 - MoF
KWSP peruntuk RM97 bilion atau 83 peratus daripada jumlah peruntukan dana untuk pelaburan domestik pada tahun ini.
Inisiatif BAITI bantu golongan M40 miliki kediaman pertama
Program inisiatif BAITI menawarkan bantuan kewangan kepada golongan M40 memiliki rumah pertama mereka di Lembah Klang dan Selangor.
KWSP catat jumlah pendapatan pelaburan RM33.19 bilion pada separuh pertama 2023
KWSP merekodkan jumlah pendapatan pelaburan sebanyak RM33.19 bilion bagi separuh tahun pertama berakhir 30 Jun, 2023.
KWSP cadang 'Akaun 3' untuk pekerja tidak formal, benarkan keluaran fleksibel
KWSP cadang Akaun 3 diberi kelonggaran untuk membuat pengeluaran sebarang jumlah pada bila-bila masa.
ISWC 2023 himpun lebih 2,000 delegasi, perkasa sistem perlindungan sosial negara
Persidangan berkenaan dilihat mampu mencari penyelesaian dan menambah baik sistem perlindungan sosial di negara ini.
Dana KWSP tidak wajar digunakan untuk biaya belanjawan defisit kerajaan - Pakar Ekonomi
Dana Kumpulan Wang Simpanan Pekerja (KWSP) tidak wajar digunakan sebagai pinjaman untuk membiayai belanjawan defisit kerajaan.
'Potong 20 peratus subsidi petrol, salurkan kepada dana pencen KWSP' - Penganalisis
20 peratus subsidi petrol wajar dipertimbangkan untuk dimansuhkan dan disalurkan kepada dana pencen kepada pencarum Kumpulan Wang Simpanan Pekerja (KWSP).
Akaun 2 jadi cagaran: KWSP masih perinci kaedah, menilai semua faktor
KWSP sedang menilai dan memperincikan kaedah terbaik serta pertimbang semua faktor yang relevan bagi memastikan pelaksanaan yang lancar.
KWSP umum dividen 5.35 peratus untuk konvensional, 4.75 peratus untuk syariah
KWSP mengumumkan agihan dividen 5.35 peratus bagi simpanan konvensional dan 4.75 peratus bagi simpanan syariah.
Semakan status pengeluaran khas KWSP bermula 9 April
Pengeluaran khas KWSP telah mula dibuka pada 1 April lalu sehingga 30 April ini.